peer review

Guidelines for peer review
Respond to two of your classmates’ synthesis papers by answering the questions below (200 words each response).   
 

Identify the things that worked well for you as a reader. What are the strengths of the paper?

How clear is the thesis?  How thoroughly does the thesis connect the papers to each other and to a larger idea?

How has the author synthesized information and ideas from all three papers throughout the essay?  

Identify one way in which you think this essay could be improved.

What have you learned from reading your classmates’ synthesis papers?